Pseudoscience in Changing Times
Thursday, November 20th, 2008I don’t know why I decided to check out Changing Times, but now that I’ve done it I can’t undo it. My life is hard.
In this issue (PDF) on page 35 there is an article by Dr. Don Colbert called “Water - How Much And What Kind”. In it, Dr. Colbert made several specific claims that I (wonder of wonders) found myself a bit skeptical of. He says that “water straight from the tap may contain toxins, heavy metals, pesticides, bacteria and other microbes.” From what I know of municipal water, which is mostly from touring a processing plant two weeks ago, all of this is painstakingly removed tap water. Chlorine kills bacteria and other organisms that live in water. Ask any aquarium owner. Maybe there are heavy metals and the ever-present “toxins”, but city governments are constantly testing for that, making sure they stay well below toxic levels. No reference was provided for this claim.
Colbert also gives a formula for determining how much water you should drink daily, but the formula seems incredibly oversimplified: Your Body Weight / 2 = Ounces of water your body needs in a day. Could it really be that simple? Maybe, but again, from what I’ve heard, it’s a lot more complicated than this, with factors such as gender, activity level, illness, temperature, humidity, and diet playing big roles. Again, no reference was provided for this claim.
Colbert then goes on to say that human urine should be basically pH neutral (no reference given) and lists 25 brands of bottled water and their respective pH value. I don’t see where he explicitly claims that the pH of the water you drink determines the pH of your urine, but it’s definitely implied. Again, it seems deceptively simple, but of course, no reference is given.
So I went to Dr. Colbert’s site and asked for references! Of course (and I think you’ll agree with me here), the moment I saw the homepage of this site I knew I’d never get those references, but I figured, “What the hell.” Here is the email I sent to them:
I recently read Dr. Colbert’s article in Changing Times
(http://changingtimes.info/images/BTS%20%2708.pdf) about water, and I was
wondering if you could provide references for a couple of claims made in the
article.Dr. Colbert says, “Water straight from the tap may contain toxins, heavy
metals, pesticides, bacteria and other microbes.” I would be interested in
seeing a reference for this claim.I would also like to see a reference for the formula given to determine who
much water a person should drink every day (”Your Body Weight ÷ 2″).Lastly, I would be interested in knowing where the information about the pH
levels for the listed brands of bottled water came from.Thank you for your time.
About thirty minutes later, they sent me this response:
Hello,
You can have your tape water tested and see if there are any chemicals,
metals, pesticides and bacteria in the water. Dr. Colbert is not against
people drinking tape water although they should have their water tested for
toxic substances. Drinking enough water through out the day is very
important for your health. People that weigh more need more fluid intake;
Dr. Colbert has received the reference (body wt/2=amount of water in ounces)
from the Anti-aging training and medical training. You can actually test
the bottle of water for the Ph like you test it with your urine. Dr.
Colbert over the years has tested several different kinds of water and
determined the most alkaline waters.The Staff at
Divine Health Wellness Center
Yeah, way to avoid the question, homeboy. What the hell is “tape water”?
Determined to make these people nervous / ignore me, I replied with the following:
Hi,
Thank you for your response. Please forgive me for being vague in my initial email. When I ask for references, what I mean is, in what peer reviewed journal articles did this information appear? If you could provide this information for the claims mentioned in my original email, it would be very helpful to me, and I would be very grateful.
Did Dr. Colbert test all the brands of water in the article for which pH values are given? How many times did he test each brand, over what period of time, and what method or methods did he use? Did he publish the results in a peer reviewed journal, and if so, which one?
Thank you very much for your time.
See how I’m getting more and more thankful for their time? After I sent this, I immediately got an autoresponder that said little more than, “Dream on! Buy my products!”
Thank you for your email to the office of Don Colbert, M.D. and Divine Health Nutritional Products.
Your email is important to us and we will answer it as soon as possible. We receive thousands of emails each week, and review and answer emails daily — with the exception of weekends and national holidays.
Dr. Colbert is aware of the many physical and spiritual needs around the world. Currently Dr. Colbert has written over 40 books addressing these needs including the Bible Cure Series of booklets which address many individual illnesses. Dr. Colbert’s newest book, the New York Times bestseller, The Seven Pillars of Health, will also answer many of your health related questions. In addition to these books, our website, www.drcolbert.com, has many articles addressing health needs which can be found by clicking on the “Medical Articles” tab on the left hand side of the home page.
If you have an order problem please call the office directly so the front desk staff can research and solve the problem.
Thank you for your patience and understanding. We will be responding to your email as soon as possible.
In His Service,
Dr. Don and Mary Colbert
And that’s where we stand right now. I really don’t expect to ever get an actual reference to a real life journal article, but it’s possible that there will be several more rounds of question skirting. If anything happens, I will let you know!








